Questions an Expert Report Can Answer
In a building dispute, the parties may disagree about what caused a defect, whether the work follows the drawings and specification, or what repairs are needed. An expert surveyor examines those questions and explains the technical findings, giving the parties and their legal advisers evidence on which to assess the dispute.
Our expert witness work also covers property condition, boundaries and residential valuations. Depending on the instruction, the report may assess the extent of defective work, compare possible causes or explain the likely cost of repairs. We establish the questions at the outset so the inspection and research address the matters that need resolving.


Inspection & Supporting Evidence
We consider site findings alongside the relevant records, which may include architectural drawings, specifications, contracts, earlier reports and correspondence. Boundary instructions can involve title documents and historic material, while residential valuation disputes need evidence of comparable property sales.
A photograph may show a defect clearly without establishing when it arose or what caused it. Its date, location and relationship to other records help us assess what it demonstrates. We distinguish findings from our own inspection from information supplied by others, and explain where concealed construction or missing evidence prevents a firm conclusion.
If repairs have already been carried out, earlier photographs, inspection notes, invoices and records of the work may be particularly useful. We review what remains available before advising whether further inspection or investigation is needed.
What the Expert Report Covers
Our CPR Part 35 expert witness reports address the questions in the instruction and explain how the evidence supports each opinion. They are addressed to the court, with the required expert declarations and statement of truth.
The expert’s duty to the court takes priority over the interests of the person instructing or paying them. Relevant evidence must therefore be considered whether it supports or challenges the conclusion, with any unresolved uncertainty made clear.
- the expert’s qualifications, relevant experience and material instructions
- the inspections, documents and other evidence relied on
- the findings, supported by photographs, drawings or schedules where these help explain the issues
- the reasoning behind the opinion, including other professional views where relevant
- assumptions, limitations and matters requiring further investigation
- reasoned conclusions on the questions the expert has been asked to address.
Single Joint Experts & Work after the Report
Single Joint Expert Appointments
A Single Joint Expert provides independent evidence for two or more parties, and the court may direct this arrangement where one expert can address the disputed issues. We accept these appointments as well as instructions from individual parties.
The questions, documents and inspection arrangements need to be established at the start. Instructions from one party must be copied to the others, so the expert’s work proceeds openly and in accordance with any court directions. The opinion follows the evidence; it is not a compromise between the parties’ positions.
Questions, Joint Statements & Hearings
After the report is served, written questions may be put to the expert to clarify the evidence. The court may also direct discussions between experts and a joint statement recording where they agree, where they disagree and why. These stages can narrow the technical issues that remain in dispute.
If oral evidence is required, the expert may attend a hearing to explain the opinion and answer questions. Replies, expert discussions and court attendance are considered against the procedural timetable and quoted separately unless included in the original appointment. Our Court Evidence & Appearance page explains these later stages.
Instructing an Expert Surveyor
To assess a proposed instruction, we need the property address, the parties’ names, the questions requiring an expert opinion and the reporting deadline. Send any proposed letter of instruction, court directions and the main documents so we can check for conflicts, confirm our availability and explain the work and fee.
Michael J Redmond Snr accepts instructions from solicitors and parties where the questions fall within his surveying or residential valuation expertise. Tell us whether the advice is for an initial assessment, negotiations or court proceedings, as this affects how the work should be prepared.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an existing survey become an expert report?
Send us the survey and the questions the expert needs to address. We can review its findings and supporting evidence, then explain what further inspection, analysis or reporting is needed. A report for court must meet CPR Part 35 requirements; adding an expert declaration to a private survey is not enough.
Can I instruct you without a solicitor?
We accept enquiries directly from parties as well as solicitors. We can explain the technical questions the report could address and the information needed, while advice on legal claims, procedure and the use of expert evidence should come from your legal adviser.
Can you advise before proceedings begin?
A preliminary assessment can help establish what the evidence shows and what further investigation would be useful before you decide how to proceed. We confirm the purpose and status of that advice at the outset. If formal expert evidence is later needed, the appointment and any earlier advisory role must be reviewed.
Do I need court permission for an expert report?
You can commission a report before proceedings begin. The court’s permission is needed to rely on expert evidence in proceedings or call an expert to give evidence, so obtaining a report does not guarantee that it can be used. Any existing directions should be checked before the instruction is agreed.
Can you work from photographs and documents?
Some questions can be addressed from reliable records, but defects, dimensions or concealed construction may need inspection or measurement. We review the evidence available before recommending the work. Where the original condition has changed, the report explains what can be established and which conclusions remain qualified.
How long does an expert report take?
Timing depends on the questions, volume of documents, access for inspection and any further investigation needed. Send the reporting deadline and relevant court dates with the initial enquiry so we can confirm availability and a realistic programme before you appoint us.


