The Valuation Instruction & Independent Duty

When a Part 35 Valuation Is Needed

We prepare expert residential valuation reports where property value is an issue in civil proceedings in England and Wales. The report gives the court an independent opinion and explains the evidence behind it, addressing the property interest, valuation date and questions raised by the case.

Our Duty to the Court

Under CPR Part 35, our duty is to help the court, taking priority over obligations to the person instructing or paying us. We weigh the evidence objectively, considering material that supports or challenges the valuation, and explain any uncertainty that affects our conclusions.

Long reception room with connecting doorways and varied internal finishes
Property layout & accommodation

Inspection, Evidence & Valuation Reasoning

We inspect the property and examine sales evidence relevant to the valuation date, comparing location, size, accommodation, condition and tenure. The report explains which transactions we have relied on, how they differ from the property and how they support our opinion of value.

Where a disputed fact could affect the valuation, we identify it and explain the assumptions used. We distinguish what we observed during the inspection from information supplied by others, so the basis of our opinion can be examined.

What the Part 35 Report Covers

Our expert valuations follow the applicable RICS Red Book standards, with reports addressed to the court and prepared to the requirements of CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35. Alongside our opinion of value, the report sets out:

  • The expert’s qualifications and material instructions.
  • The property interest, valuation date and basis of valuation.
  • The facts, inspection findings and market evidence relied upon.
  • The reasons for the opinion and any relevant range of opinion.
  • Assumptions, limitations and any qualifications to the conclusions.
  • The required declarations and statement of truth.

Joint Instructions & Later Evidence Stages

Single Joint Expert Instructions

The court may direct a single joint expert appointment, with one expert providing an independent valuation for two or more parties. We accept these appointments and assess the evidence independently of each party’s preferred outcome. Any party giving instructions must send a copy to the other relevant parties at the same time.

After the Report

Further work may include answering written questions, discussions with another expert, a joint statement or attendance at court. We quote for these stages separately, taking account of the court’s directions and timetable. If new evidence changes our opinion, we explain the change and the reasons for it.

Family Proceedings: FPR Part 25

Expert valuation evidence in divorce and other family proceedings follows Part 25 of the Family Procedure Rules (FPR), while CPR Part 35 applies to civil proceedings. Our FPR Part 25 Compliant Valuations service covers family court appointments; for private settlement discussions or negotiations, see Matrimonial Valuations.

Documents We Need

Before accepting an appointment, we review the valuation questions, check for conflicts of interest and confirm that we can meet the reporting deadline. Please send:

  • The property address and ownership interest to be valued.
  • The required valuation date.
  • The proposed instructions and questions to be answered.
  • Any court order or directions already issued.
  • The names of the parties and their solicitors.
  • Existing valuations and relevant property documents.
  • Case papers or correspondence relating to the valuation issue.
  • The reporting deadline and any hearing date.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I commission a report before court permission?

Yes. A report can be commissioned before the court gives permission, but permission is needed to rely on it as expert evidence or call the expert at trial. We review the proposed instructions and any existing directions before accepting the appointment.

Can a RICS Red Book valuation be used instead?

A RICS Red Book valuation prepared for another purpose does not automatically meet the requirements for expert evidence. If you already have a valuation report, send it with the proposed instructions so we can identify what further work is needed.

Can you value a property at an earlier date?

Yes, where sufficient evidence is available. A retrospective valuation considers the property and market as they stood at the specified date, using relevant sales evidence and records of the property’s condition, such as dated photographs, plans and details of later alterations.

Can you attend court?

Yes. Court attendance is quoted separately from the valuation report. Please tell us about any hearing date when you enquire so we can check availability and allow for the preparation required.

Related Services & Guidance